Non-Biased Review of the Best Heat Pump Brands

Non-Biased Review of the Best Heat Pump Brands

Non-Biased Review of the Best Heat Pump Brands

As a highly experienced HVAC technician, I understand that choosing the right heat pump brand can be overwhelming due to the sheer number of available options.

While most top heat pump brands offer similar features and functionalities, their internal components, manufacturing locations, and warranties can vary significantly.

Therefore, I will provide an impartial review of this article’s major heat pump brands, considering several crucial factors when selecting a heat pump brand.

By the end of this article, you will clearly understand what makes a top-rated heat pump brand and how to choose the one that best suits your needs.

⭐ Factors to Consider When Choosing a Heat Pump Brand

Before diving into the details of each heat pump brand, let’s discuss the key factors you should consider when choosing one.

  1. Parent Company: The parent company is the first factor to consider when selecting a heat pump brand. Choosing a brand with a reputable parent company known for producing high-quality heating and cooling systems is essential.
  2. Manufacturing Location: The manufacturing location of the heat pump is another critical factor to consider. Brands manufacturing their heat pumps in countries with strict quality control regulations and standards are often more reliable and durable.
  3. Internal Components: The internal components of a heat pump, including the compressor, fan, and coils, play a vital role in the unit’s performance and longevity. It’s essential to choose a brand that uses high-quality internal components that are durable and long-lasting.
  4. Warranty: Warranty is another crucial factor when selecting a heat pump brand. Brands that offer more extended warranties, both for the standard and significant components, are often more reliable and trustworthy.
  5. Energy Efficiency Options: Energy efficiency is critical when selecting an efficient heat pump brand. Brands offering high-efficiency heat pumps can significantly reduce energy bills and carbon footprint.
  6. Standard and Advanced Features: A heat pump brand’s standard and advanced features can significantly impact your overall satisfaction with the unit. Look for brands that offer features such as programmable thermostats, air purifiers, and intelligent controls.
  7. Purchase and Repair Price Ratings: A heat pump brand’s purchase and repair price ratings are also essential factors to consider. Brands that offer high-quality heat pumps at an affordable price point with low repair costs are often more appealing to consumers.
  8. Customer Reviews: Finally, customer reviews can provide valuable insights into the reliability and performance of a heat pump brand. Look for brands with positive customer reviews and high ratings to ensure you invest in a high-quality heat pump.

⭐ What Makes a Top-Rated Heat Pump Brand?

A happy HVAC technician with a heat pump vs air conditioning

Assuming you have a gas furnace, an unlimited budget, and don’t need to worry about the cost of repairing your heat pump, a top-rated heat pump brand should offer the following features:

  1. Reliability – The brand should be known for producing reliable, durable heat pumps lasting many years.
  2. Energy Efficiency – The heat pump should be energy efficient, helping you save money on your energy bills while reducing your carbon footprint.
  3. Quiet Operation – The heat pump should operate quietly without producing excessive noise that can disrupt your daily activities.
  4. Local Manufacturing – The brand should manufacture its heat pumps locally, ensuring that you receive a unit built to last and meet your specific needs.

⭐ Heat Pumps: What Makes Them Reliable, Quiet, and Energy-Efficient?

How Does A Heat Pump Work

As with air conditioners, the reliability of a heat pump depends on the quality of its components and the installation process.

A well-made, efficient heat pump, with quality control measures in place will have fewer breakdowns and require less maintenance.

⚙️ What Makes a Heat Pump Quiet?

Manufacturers use features such as a variable-speed compressor and a modulating fan motor to make a heat pump quieter.

These components help the heat pump operate at a lower speed, reducing the amount of noise it produces.

However, it’s important to note that the design of the ducting system also plays a significant role in the noise level of a heat pump.

Pro Fact: Heat pumps can also operate in reverse, providing warmth during cold weather months.

⚙️ What Makes a Heat Pump Energy-Efficient?

The energy efficiency of a heat pump is determined by its SEER rating and the efficiency of its components.

A high SEER rating indicates that the heat pump can effectively move heat while using less energy.

Variable-speed compressors and advanced fan motors also help to increase a heat pump’s energy efficiency.

Heat pumps can also be geothermal, meaning they use the earth’s constant temperature to heat and cool a building.

Geothermal heat pumps are among the most energy-efficient heating and cooling systems available.

⚙️ What Makes a Heat Pump “Made Locally”?

As with air conditioners, the term “made locally” is somewhat misleading when it comes to heat pumps.

However, a heat pump that is assembled in a particular country likely has more locally sourced components than one that is not.

As with air conditioners, a higher percentage of locally sourced components generally means better quality control and reliability.

It’s worth noting that some manufacturers of heat pumps and air conditioners offer incentives or rebates for purchasing products made in the same country where they are being installed.

These incentives can help offset the cost of purchasing a more expensive locally-made product.

Phyxter Home Services HVAC Tech installing a Coleman Heat Pump

⭐ List of the Best Heat Pump Brands in No Specific Order

Heat pumps are becoming increasingly popular as a year-round home heating and cooling solution.

Here is a list of the top heat pump brands currently available:

  • Daikin/ Goodman/ Amana
  • JCI/ York/ Luxaire/ Coleman
  • American Standard/ Trane/ Ameristar/ Oxbox
  • Carrier/ Bryant/ Payne
  • ICP/ Comfortmaker/ ArcoAire/ Heil/ Keeprite/ Tempstar
  • Lennox/ Concord/ Armstrong Air/ Ducane/ Aire-Flo
  • Rheem/ Ruud
  • Mitsubishi Electric
  • Fujitsu

⭐ Non-Biased Review of Each of the Best Heat Pump Brands

heat pump installation

Heat pumps have become popular for homeowners looking for an energy-efficient and versatile heating and cooling solution.

This article will provide an impartial overview of the best heat pump brands available in the market.

It is important to note that this article only covers central heat pump brands.

We have yet to rate other types of heat pumps, such as ductless mini-split systems or geothermal heat pumps.

However, we plan to include them in future articles.

We have also excluded brands specializing in one type of heat pump, such as air source heat pumps or water source heat pumps.

This list only includes brands that offer a variety of heat pump options for residential use.

⭐American Standard/ Ingersoll Rand/ Trane/ Ameristar/ Oxbox

American Standard

  • Parent Company: Ingersoll Rand Manufacturer
  • Location: United States
  • Manufacturer of Each Internal Component: Not disclosed
  • Standard Component Warranty: 10-year limited warranty on parts
  • Major Component Warranty: 10-year limited warranty on compressors
  • Energy Efficiency Options: High SEER ratings available
  • Standard Features: Wi-Fi enabled, corrosion-resistant cabinets, multiple fan speeds
  • Advanced Features: AccuClean technology for improved air quality, dual fuel compatibility
  • Purchase Price Rating: High
  • Repair Price Rating: High
  • Customer Reviews: Generally positive, with customers praising the brand’s reliability and energy efficiency.

American Standard is a reputable parent company that is known for producing high-quality HVAC equipment, and American Standard is no exception.

The brand offers a range of energy-efficient air conditioning units with high SEER ratings and Wi-Fi-enabled features for remote access and control.

American Standard’s products come with a 10-year limited warranty on parts and compressors, which is standard for the industry.

However, the brand’s purchase and repair prices tend to be on the higher side, which may not be ideal for customers on a tight budget.

Trane Heat Pump

  • Parent Company: Ingersoll Rand
  • Manufacturer Location: United States
  • Manufacturer of Each Internal Component: Not disclosed Standard Component
  • Warranty: 10-year limited warranty on parts
  • Major Component Warranty: 10-year limited warranty on compressors
  • Energy Efficiency Options: High SEER ratings available
  • Standard Features: Wi-Fi enabled, corrosion-resistant cabinets, multiple fan speeds
  • Advanced Features: ComfortLink II technology for improved energy efficiency, dual fuel compatibility
  • Purchase Price Rating: High
  • Repair Price Rating: High
  • Customer Reviews: Generally positive, with customers praising the brand’s reliability and energy efficiency.

Trane is another brand under the Ingersoll Rand umbrella, and like American Standard, it offers a range of high-quality air conditioning units.

The brand’s products are known for their energy efficiency, with advanced features like ComfortLink II technology that help improve overall energy efficiency.

Trane also offers a 10-year limited warranty on parts and compressors, which is standard for the industry.

However, the brand’s purchase and repair prices tend to be on the higher side, which may not be suitable for customers on a tight budget.

Ameristar

  • Parent Company: Ingersoll Rand
  • Manufacturer Location: United States
  • Manufacturer of Each Internal Component: Not disclosed
  • Standard Component Warranty: 10-year limited warranty on parts
  • Major Component Warranty: 10-year limited warranty on compressors
  • Efficiency Options: Moderate to high SEER ratings available
  • Standard Features: Corrosion-resistant cabinets, multiple fan speeds
  • Advanced Features: Not applicable
  • Purchase Price Rating: Low to moderate
  • Repair Price Rating: Low to moderate
  • Customer Reviews: Mixed, with some customers praising the brand’s affordability while others have had issues with reliability.

Ameristar is a budget-friendly brand under the Ingersoll Rand umbrella.

While its products may not have all the advanced features of other brands, Ameristar offers reliable air conditioning units with moderate to high SEER ratings.

The brand’s products come with a 10-year limited warranty on parts and compressors, which is standard for the industry.

Ameristar’s purchase and repair prices tend to be on the lower side, making it an attractive option for customers on a tight budget.

However, some customers have reported reliability issues with the brand’s products, so weighing the cost savings against potential repair costs is important.

Oxbox

  • Parent Company: Allied Air
  • Manufacturer Location: United States
  • Reliability: Oxbox heat pumps are designed to be reliable with features such as high-quality compressors and durable materials. However, the brand’s limited market presence and lack of history may raise some concerns about its long-term reliability.
  • Energy Efficiency: Oxbox heat pumps are highly energy efficient, with SEER ratings ranging from 14 to 22. The brand also offers variable-speed compressors and low-noise operation, making them an excellent choice for those looking to save on energy bills.
  • Noise Level: Oxbox heat pumps operate at relatively low noise levels thanks to features such as the modulating fan motor and variable-speed compressor. This makes them a good option for homeowners who prioritize quiet operations.
  • Made Locally: Oxbox heat pumps are assembled in the United States using components sourced from various countries. While this may not be a deal-breaker for some, others may prefer brands that use more locally sourced components.

Overall, Oxbox heat pumps are a solid choice for those looking for a reliable, energy-efficient option with low noise levels.

However, their limited market presence and lack of history may be a concern for some buyers.

Carrier Heat Pump

Carrier Global Corporation is the parent company of Carrier heat pumps.

The heat pumps are assembled in various United States and Mexico locations.

The manufacturer of each internal component can be seen in the chart below.

The standard component warranty is ten years, but it drops to 5 years if the heat pump is not registered within 90 days of purchase.

The compressor warranty is also ten years.

Available models of Carrier heat pumps include the Infinity, Performance, and Comfort series.

The available energy efficiency options go up to 21 SEER.

Standard features include constant torque or variable speed ECM motors, single-stage, two-stage, or modulating compressor options, steel louvered coil guard, high and low-pressure switches, galvanized steel cabinet, and Energy Star Certification.

Advanced energy savings features are not applicable.

Carrier heat pumps have a high purchase price rating and a high repair price rating.

Customer reviews are mixed, with some reporting issues with reliability and high repair costs, while others are satisfied with the brand’s performance.

Bryant Heat Pump

Bryant heat pumps are also part of the Carrier Global Corporation, assembled in various locations in the United States and Mexico, and the manufacturer of each internal component is seen in online charts.

The standard component warranty is ten years, but it drops to 5 years if the heat pump is not registered within 90 days of purchase.

The compressor warranty is also ten years.

The available models of Bryant heat pumps include the Evolution, Preferred, and Legacy series, with available energy efficiency options going up to 20.5 SEER.

Standard features are constant torque or variable speed ECM motors, single-stage, two-stage, or modulating compressor options, steel louvered coil guard, high and low-pressure switches, galvanized steel cabinet, and Energy Star Certification.

Advanced features are not applicable.

Bryant heat pumps have a high purchase price rating and a high repair price rating.

Customer reviews are mixed, with some reporting issues with reliability and high repair costs, while others are satisfied with the brand’s performance.

Payne Heat Pumps

Payne heat pumps are also part of the Carrier Global Corporation, assembled in various locations in the United States and Mexico, and the manufacturer of each internal component is seen in online charts.

The standard component warranty is ten years, but it drops to 5 years if the heat pump unit is not registered within 90 days of purchase.

The compressor warranty is also ten years.

The available models of Payne heat pumps include the Legacy series, with available energy efficiency options going up to 16 SEER.

Standard features of best heat pumps include constant torque or variable speed ECM motors, single-stage or two-stage compressor options, wire coil guards, high and low-pressure switches, and galvanized steel cabinets.

Advanced features are not applicable.

Payne heat pumps have a low purchase price rating and a low repair price rating.

Customer reviews are mixed, with some reporting issues with reliability and high repair costs, while others are satisfied with the brand’s performance, especially for the price point.

⭐ Lennox/ Concord/ Armstrong Air/ Ducane/ Aire-Flo

When it comes to choosing the right heating and cooling system for your home or business, there are a lot of factors to consider.

One of the most important decisions you’ll need to make is which brand of central air and ductless heat pumps to choose.

In this review, we’ll take a closer look at five popular brands: Lennox, Concord, Armstrong Air, Ducane, and Aire-Flo.

We’ll examine their features, reliability, energy efficiency, and overall performance to help you make an informed decision.

Lennox Heat Pump

Lennox is a well-known brand in the HVAC industry and has been in business for over a century.

They offer a wide range of central air and ductless heat pump systems for both residential and commercial applications.

One of the standout features of Lennox systems is their energy efficiency.

Many of their products are ENERGY STAR certified, meaning they meet strict energy efficiency guidelines set by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency.

This can help you save money on your energy bills and reduce your carbon footprint.

Another benefit of Lennox systems is their quiet operation.

Many of their models feature advanced sound-dampening technology, which can make them much quieter than other brands.

This is especially important if you have a small home or office, as loud HVAC systems can be distracting and disruptive.

Lennox also offers a wide range of features and options to customize your system.

For example, many of their models come with advanced air filtration systems that can help remove pollutants and allergens from the air.

They also offer smart thermostats that allow you to control your HVAC system from your phone or another mobile device.

One potential downside of Lennox systems is their cost.

They tend to be more expensive than some other brands, which may not be feasible for everyone’s budget.

However, many customers find that the quality and reliability of Lennox systems are worth the investment.

Concord Heat Pump

Concord is a subsidiary of Lennox and offers a range of affordable central air and ductless air source heat pump systems.

These systems are designed to provide reliable performance and energy efficiency at a lower cost than some other brands.

While they may not have all the bells and whistles of Lennox systems, they still offer many of the same benefits.

One of the standout features of Concord systems is their reliability.

They are built to last and are designed to withstand the rigors of daily use.

They also come with a solid warranty, which can give you peace of mind in the event of a breakdown or other issues.

Another benefit of Concord systems is their ease of installation.

They are designed to be easy to install, which can save you time and money on installation costs.

They also require minimal maintenance, which can further reduce your overall costs over time.

However, one potential downside of Concord Systems is its limited options.

They may not have as many features or customization options as some other brands.

Additionally, while they are energy-efficient, they may not be as efficient as some of the higher-end Lennox systems.

Armstrong Air Heat Pump

Armstrong Air is a relatively new player in the HVAC industry, having been in business for just over a decade.

However, they have quickly made a name for themselves by offering high-quality central air and ductless air conditioner and heat pump systems at an affordable price.

One of the standout features of Armstrong Air systems is their durability.

They are built to last and are designed to withstand extreme weather conditions and other challenges.

They also come with a solid warranty, which can give you peace of mind in the event of a breakdown or other issues.

Another benefit of Armstrong Air systems is their energy efficiency.

Many of their models are ENERGY STAR certified, meaning they meet strict energy efficiency guidelines set by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency.

This can help you save money on your energy bills and reduce your carbon footprint.

One potential downside of Armstrong Air systems is their limited availability.

They are not as widely available as some other brands, which can make it difficult to find a local dealer or installer.

This can also make finding replacement parts or services more difficult if needed.

Additionally, while Armstrong Air systems are known for their durability, they may not have as many customization options or features as some other brands.

This may not be a concern for all customers, but those who want more control over their HVAC system may prefer a different brand.

Ducane Heat Pump

Ducane is another brand that offers affordable central air and ductless heat pump systems.

They are known for their high-quality products and reliable performance.

One of the standout features of Ducane systems is their energy efficiency.

Many of their models are ENERGY STAR certified, meaning they meet strict energy efficiency guidelines set by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency.

This can help you save money on your energy bills and reduce your carbon footprint.

Another benefit of Ducane systems is their ease of installation.

They are designed to be easy to install, which can save you time and money on installation costs.

They also require minimal maintenance, which can further reduce your overall costs over time.

Ducane also offers a wide range of features and options to customize your system.

For example, many of their models come with advanced air filtration systems that can help remove pollutants and allergens from the air.

They also offer smart thermostats that allow you to control your HVAC system from your phone or another mobile device.

However, one potential downside of Ducane systems is their limited availability.

They are not as widely available as some other brands, which can make it difficult to find a local dealer or installer.

This can also make finding replacement parts or services more difficult if needed.

Aire-Flo Heat Pump

Aire-Flo is a budget-friendly brand that offers a range of central air and ductless heat pump systems.

They are designed to provide reliable performance and energy efficiency at a lower cost than some other brands.

One of the standout features of Aire-Flo heating systems, is their affordability.

They are one of the most budget-friendly brands on the market, making them a great choice for those on a tight budget.

Another benefit of Aire-Flo systems is their reliability.

They are built to last and are designed to withstand the rigors of daily use.

They also come with a solid warranty, which can give you peace of mind in the event of a breakdown or other issues.

Aire-Flo also offers a range of features and options to customize your system.

For example, many of their models come with advanced air filtration systems that can help remove pollutants and allergens from the air.

They also offer smart thermostats that allow you to control your HVAC system from your phone or other mobile devices.

However, one potential downside of Aire-Flo systems is their limited options.

They may not have as many features or customization options as some other brands.

Additionally, while they are energy-efficient, they may not be as efficient as some of the higher-end brands.

⭐ Overall Review of Heat Pump Buying Criteria

woman thinking about her heat pump

Heat pumps are an increasingly popular home heating and cooling option, providing a more energy-efficient and environmentally friendly alternative to traditional HVAC systems.

When considering a heat pump system for your home, it’s important to understand the different types of systems available and how they can impact your purchase price and monthly utility bills.

This article will discuss the differences between single-stage, two-stage, and variable-capacity heat pumps.

What are Single-Stage Heat Pumps?

Single-stage heat pumps are systems with only one heating and cooling output level.

It operates at total capacity when turned on and shuts off completely when the desired temperature is reached.

These systems have the lowest initial cost but the highest monthly operating cost, as they are less energy-efficient.

What are Two-Stage Heat Pumps?

Two-stage heat pumps are systems that have two levels of heating and cooling output.

The first stage is a lower output that is used to maintain the temperature on mild days.

In contrast, the second stage provides a maximum output on colder or hotter days.

These systems are more energy-efficient than single-stage systems and offer better temperature control.

What are Variable Capacity Heat Pumps?

A variable capacity or modulating heat pump is an energy-efficient system that adjusts the heating and cooling output continuously based on the temperature inside and outside the home.

It can operate at any level between 40% and 100% of capacity, providing the most precise temperature control and highest energy efficiency.

However, modulating systems have the highest initial cost.

Understanding Energy Efficiency for Heat Pumps

When considering a heat pump, energy efficiency is a crucial factor to consider.

The higher the Seasonal Energy Efficiency Ratio (SEER) and Heating Seasonal Performance Factor (HSPF) ratings, the more energy-efficient the system is.

It’s essential to calculate how much you would save each month with a more energy-efficient heat pump system and compare it to the additional cost of the system.

The payback period for the upgrade should be reasonable.

How Much Does a New Heat Pump Cost?

The cost of heat pumps varies based on the type of heating system used, the contractor, and other factors like size, brand, and efficiency.

It’s essential to determine what factors are most important to you before beginning your search and create a shortlist of systems that meet those requirements.

Then, you can filter the list further based on other factors like cost and warranty.

Is a Heat Pump Warranty Important?

Yes, a heat pump warranty is essential.

A well-installed system can last for many years, but some contractors don’t follow manufacturer recommendations during installation, leading to issues.

Look for a warranty with good coverage and protection, like a limited first-year unit replacement.

What are the Best Heat Pump Brands?

Your best heat pump brand will depend on your specific needs and preferences.

Some factors to consider include value for the dollar, warranty, quality, repair pricing, and manufacturing location.

Lennox, Trane, Carrier, and even Rheem heat pumps are all good brands to consider based on their value for the dollar, reliability, and quality components.

When choosing the best heat pump brand for you, it’s essential to consider all these variables and trust your contractor to have your back.

Look for a highly-rated contractor with years of experience, good communication skills, and a track record of reliability.

If they can’t attend your quote inspection on time, it may be a sign of poor respect for your time and needs.

⭐ My Final Comment on the Best Heat Pump Brands

Phyxter Approved Logo on Service Truck

Understanding the differences between single-stage, two-stage, and modulating systems is essential when purchasing a heat pump.

Consider the energy efficiency, price range, warranty, and brand when choosing a system, and find a trustworthy contractor to install and service it for the best results.

If you want to learn more about the heat pump industry, reach out to us for new blog article topics.

Jake Gibson

Jake Gibson is a force to be reckoned with in the HVAC industry. As the CEO of Phyxter, he has made it his mission to revolutionize how contractors work. With a background in HVAC, entrepreneurship, and technology, Jake brings innovation and expertise to this traditional industry.

About our blog

Phyxter (pronounced Fix-ter) is a national home services brand specializing in Residential HVAC, Electrical and Plumbing solutions.

Phyxter is laser-focused on writing the best articles and guides to empower homeowners to get the best out of their homes.

We hope you enjoy it!

Looking for something?

Join our Newsletter!