Can a Circuit Breaker Fail Without Tripping? Your DIY Guide!

Can a Circuit Breaker Fail Without Tripping

Can a Circuit Breaker Fail Without Tripping?

The simple answer is: YES, if you have a bad circuit breaker. 

Having circuit breakers trip isn’t a sign of a faulty breaker, but if one fails to trip when necessary, it’s time to take action.

When the power goes out, most of us head straight to our circuit breaker.

But what happens if your power goes out and your circuit breaker doesn’t trip?

failed circuit breaker can be a danger to your home’s safety and may eventually lead to electrical fires and the risk of electric shock.

There are so many reasons why circuit breakers trip that it’s worthwhile doing a bit of investigation and gaining an understanding of your home’s electrical system.

Doing so will help you make the right decision about when to call a professional and when an electrical trip is normal.

Why Do Circuit Breakers Trip?

Tripped Circuit Breaker

Circuit breakers act as a safety valve for the circuits in your home.

Modern appliances have become increasingly power-hungry, leading to overloaded circuits.

If electricity keeps flowing through these overloaded circuits, the risk of a short circuit becomes higher.

Short circuits are the leading cause of electrical fires and electric shocks and can be fatal.

The purpose of the breaker box is to protect your appliances from a faulty current or faulty wiring.

When the breaker detects an electrical overload, it will immediately trip, severing the connection that keeps electricity flowing through that particular circuit.

In fact, a tripping circuit breaker is actually one that’s working correctly.

So, if you have a breaker box that does trip immediately when you plug in an appliance, it’s an indication that the circuit breaker panel works as intended.

Overloaded circuits are relatively common, especially after a home improvement. 

Homeowners put in many plugs and new electrical components but don’t consider how that extra electricity flowing can lead to electrical issues.

For more information on AC circuit breakers, check out:  Top 9 Reasons Your AC Breaker Keeps Tripping.

Can a Circuit Breaker Fail Without Tripping?

If you’ve lost power to a circuit, but your circuit breaker hasn’t tripped, it can indicate that your circuit breaker is bad and needs replacing. There are many reasons why a circuit breaker can fail, including high ambient heat and low voltage. This means that a bad breaker doesn’t detect a power surge or more electricity than the circuit can handle.

So instead of tripping to break the connection, the breaker allows more energy to flow through the circuit, causing it to heat up.

A bad breaker will often allow an electrical system to operate at a much higher capacity, increasing the risk of fires and other serious electrical issues.

Surprisingly, circuit breakers need a minimum voltage to function correctly.

For example, an electrical panel needs at least 120 V for a single-pole breaker and 240 V for a double-pole breaker.

If the breaker box doesn’t receive this minimum voltage, it can start to fail and go bad, leading to electrical issues and potential fire hazards.

Signs of a Faulty Breaker

burnt out circuit breaker

The most obvious sign of a fault breaker is that it doesn’t trip when the power goes out.

However, you should also keep an eye out for other signs of a faulty circuit breaker, such as:

  • A burning smell coming from the electrical panel.
  • The circuit breaker is hot to the touch.
  • Obvious signs of wear

Most homeowners aren’t aware, but circuit breakers have a set lifespan and may need replacing.

  • Burned or melted parts.
  • Ragged wires running to and from the breaker.

Ground fault issues from an exposed wire are common problems.

  • Flickering lights often indicate a problem with your home’s circuits
  • Delayed tripping

Such as a trip halfway during your use of a power-hungry device.

A faulty circuit breaker needs immediate attention, but there is a simple check to see if your circuit breaker is broken or another electrical issue.

For instance, if you consistently overload your system with multiple appliances, simply changing your behavior can mitigate your electrical issues.

However, a failing circuit breaker represents a significant hazard, and it’s worth getting a professional to take a closer look.

Remember that a tripping breaker is functioning properly. The point of a fuse box is to protect your wires and appliances from overloaded or short circuits.

Testing Your Circuit Breaker

Before you test your circuit breaker, make sure that you have the following tools:

  • Insulated electrician’s gloves
  • Digital multimeter. (Here’s our recommendation if you need one)


If you’re not a professional, avoid trying to remove the circuit breaker or repairing a faulty switch by yourself.

Once you’ve determined if the issue is more amps than your electrical system can handle.

Which is causing a circuit overload or a bad breaker; call a professional electrician to continue the repairs.

📗 Related Reading: Homeowners Guide to Electrical Safety

Female Electrician

Testing Your Circuit Breaker

Identify the Breaker and What it’s Protecting.


Take a look at the circuit breaker panel or circuit box and find the corresponding room where you have your issue.

Use this opportunity to check for any burning smell or other signs of wear and tear on the breaker panel.

Unplug the Relevant Appliances and Devices

unplugged electrical device

Once you’ve found the relevant circuit, unplug any electrical devices connected to that circuit.

Again, if you’re not 100% of what electrical components connect to a particular circuit, err on the side of caution and unplug all of your electrical devices.

Reset the Circuit Breaker

reset circuit breaker

If the switch still works, reset the circuit breaker.

You can do this by moving the switch to the OFF position and then back into the ON position.

Now you can check what the circuit breaker does when you plug your appliances back in. 

If the circuit breaker trips immediately, then the problem is either a short circuit or your circuit breaker is bad.

If it doesn’t trip immediately but trips later when your devices power up, it means that you have an overloaded circuit.

An overloaded circuit happens when you pull more amps than your electrical system can handle.

The tripped circuit breaker means that it isn’t the problem; you need to consider moving the electrical current to another non-overloaded circuit.

Measure the Voltage

electrician checking breaker

A slightly more advanced way of checking if you have a bad breaker is with a digital multimeter.

You don’t need a professional electrician’s high-end multimeter; just a simple one will do fine.

As with the previous steps, disconnect your appliances from the circuit. 

Make sure the switch is in the OFF position. 

Remove the panel screws and gently remove the cover from the box.

Get your multimeter ready by plugging the red probe into the V port and the black probe into the COMMON port.

Doing so will allow you to measure the voltage and current running through a conductor.

Then take the end of the red wire and place it against the breaker screw you want to test and the end of the black wire against the neutral bar.

The multimeter will then display a voltage if you have a functioning circuit breaker.

You should either see 120 V for a single-pole or between 220 and 250 V for a double-pole circuit breaker.

If the multimeter shows 0 V, then you know that you’ve got a bad circuit breaker, and it’s time to call an electrician.


  • Insulated electrician’s gloves
  • Digital multimeter.

What to Do if Your Circuit Breakers Trip

Phyxter Electrician conducting a Circuit Breaker Inspection

Whether you have a malfunctioning panel or if your circuit breaker trips immediately – indicating a short circuit, your first step is always to contact a professional electrician.

Circuit breakers play a vital role in ensuring that no more electricity passes through your circuit than is safe.

While you can do a small test and unplug your appliances, reset your breaker and see what happens, the best course of action is to consult a professional.


Working with your home’s wires can be dangerous, unlike other DIY projects.

However, electricians understand the risks of their work and have the know-how to mitigate them.

You may think a quick replacement is simple with a circuit breaker fails, but it requires experience and an understanding of electrical safety.

Electrical Repair? Fix-It With Phyxter

Phyxter Approved Logo on Service Truck

Don’t delay when it comes to electrical issues. 

A faulty circuit is a massive fire hazard that can lead to electrical fires or shocks.

In the meanwhile, make sure that you’re not overloading your circuits with excessive appliances.

If you have multiple power strips packed with plugs, the chances are that you’re the cause of the short circuit every time you start up multiple power-hungry devices at once. 

Consider adjusting your usage or moving appliances onto a different, less-overloaded circuit.

If you live in the North or Central Okanagan area and need an electrical professional to diagnose your electrical issues, contact Phyxter Home Services.

We’ll send one of our trusted electricians to diagnose your problem and recommend the appropriate repair.

You can count on exceptional service and affordable prices when you hire Phyxter Home Services for your electrical needs.

Want to learn more about your home’s electrical system? Check out our other electrical articles.

Related Reading: Circuit Woes: When Your Electrical Breaker Keeps Tripping

Logan Mullin

Born and raised in Fairbanks, Alaska. Logan is the Electrical Manager and Master Electrician for Vernon Air Conditioning, Plumbing & Electrical Services based in the North Okanagan Valley.

About our blog

Phyxter (pronounced Fix-ter) is a national home services brand specializing in Residential HVAC, Electrical and Plumbing solutions.

Phyxter is laser-focused on writing the best articles and guides to empower homeowners to get the best out of their homes.

We hope you enjoy it!

Looking for something?

Join our Newsletter!